OPINION By MP Simon: Prime Minister Browne and the UPP: A Contradiction of Criticism and Recruitment

Prime Minister Browne and the UPP: A Contradiction of Criticism and Recruitment

by Hon. Kelvin Simon

Prime Minister Gaston Browne’s leadership is marred by a troubling pattern of disparaging others. His frequent criticism of the United Progressive Party (UPP) candidates for their perceived lack of education, experience, and maturity raises important questions—not just about his political strategy, but also about his leadership style.

For all the strengths Browne brings to the table, there appears to be an underlying insecurity that manifests in his need to demean others to elevate himself. This approach undermines his credibility and diminishes his stature as a leader. True leadership requires humility, foresight, and the ability to inspire people by connecting with their aspirations and shared values. Instead of tearing others down, Browne should strive to be a motivational leader, empowering citizens to reach their fullest potential.

There’s a clear irony in Browne’s attacks. Every time he criticizes a UPP member for not having tertiary education, he inadvertently insults thousands of Antiguans and Barbudans who are in the same position. Before the UWI campus was established in Antigua, many citizens relied on on-the-job training to contribute meaningfully to the nation. Members of his own party have thrived as civil servants without university degrees. Even Browne himself, when he first entered politics, did not hold a degree. If he could rise to prominence through determination and training, others deserve the same respect and opportunity. Leadership should be about uplifting others, not looking down on them.

Moreover, Browne’s actions reveal a contradictory strategy. While publicly dismissing UPP members, he has recruited more of them into his team than any other leader in Antigua and Barbuda’s history. This suggests that, despite his harsh words, he recognizes the talent within the opposition ranks. It also raises questions about the depth of capability within his own Antigua and Barbuda Labour Party (ABLP) if he must repeatedly turn to his political adversaries to bolster his team.

Adding to the complexity, Browne’s overconfidence continues to alienate voters. Before the last election, he boldly predicted a “clean sweep” at the polls, only to scrape by with the narrowest victory in the country’s history. He is now making the same prediction for the next election, but such arrogance risks backfiring. Political landscapes are unpredictable, and voters may reject hubris in favor of leaders who demonstrate humility and vision.

Browne must also be mindful of his own vulnerabilities. There are skeletons in his closet that others could weaponize to ridicule him, but that would not advance the political discourse Antigua and Barbuda deserves. Instead, Browne should adjust his rhetoric to reflect the hopes and aspirations of his people. The electorate is looking for a leader who inspires, not one who divides.

If Browne is to leave a lasting legacy, he must embrace a leadership style that is less combative and more constructive. Antigua and Barbuda need leaders who build bridges, foster unity, and guide the nation toward a brighter future—not by tearing others down, but by lifting everyone up.

Advertise with the mоѕt vіѕіtеd nеwѕ ѕіtе іn Antigua! We offer fully customizable and flexible digital marketing packages.Contact us at [email protected]